Truth is One Paths are Many
A Comparative Study of various Traditions
& Philosophy of Several World Religions
 
   
   
   
 
Comparing the Four Sections of Hindu Religion
Saivism, Sāktism, Vaishnavism and Smārthism
 
   
 
The spectrum of Hindu religiousness is found within four major sects or denominations:
Saivism, Sāktism, Vaishnavism and Smārthism.
Among these four streams, there are certainly more similarities than differences.
Many of the Slokas and bhāshyas of Dancing with Siva (Sivena saha Nartanam):
Hinduism's Contemporary Catechism (Sanātana Dharma Prasnottaram)
have shown how they concur as well as differ.

All four believe in karma and reincarnation and in a Supreme Being who is both form and pervades form, who creates, sustains and destroys the universe only to create it again in unending cycles. They strongly declare the validity and importance of temple worship, in the three worlds of existence and the myriad Gods and devas residing in them. They concur that there is no intrinsic evil, that the cosmos is created out of God and is permeated by Him. They each believe in māyā (though their definitions differ somewhat), and in the liberation of the soul from rebirth, called moksha, as the goal of human existence. They believe in dharma and in ahimsā, noninjury, and in the need for a satguru to lead the soul toward Self Realization. They wear the sacred marks, tilaka, on their foreheads as sacred symbols, though each wears a distinct mark. Finally, they prefer cremation of the body upon death, believing that the soul will inhabit another body in the next life. While Hinduism has many sacred scriptures, all sects ascribe the highest authority to the Vedas and Ćgamas, though their Ćgamas differ somewhat. Here, now, is a brief comparison of these four denominations.

 

On the Personal God/Goddess

Saivism: Personal God and temple Deity is Siva, neither male nor female. Lords Ganesa and Kārttikeya are also worshiped.
Sāktism: Personal Goddess and temple Deity is Srī Devī or Sakti, female, worshiped as the Divine Mother: Rājarājesvarī, Pārvati, Lakshmi, Sarasvati, Kāli, Amman, etc. .
Vaishnavism: Personal God and temple Deity is Vishnu, male. His incarnations as Rāma and Krishna are also worshiped, as well as His divine consort, Rādhā Rānī.
Smārtism: Personal God and temple Deity is Čsvara, male or female, worshiped as Vishnu, Siva, Sakti, Ganesa, Sūrya, Kumāra & Krishna or any other form of Deity of devotee's choice.

On the Nature of Sakti

Saivism: Sakti is God Siva's inseparable power and manifest will, energy or mind.
Sāktism: Sakti is an active, immanent Being, separate from a quiescent and remote Siva.
Vaishnavism: No special importance is given to Sakti. However, there are parallels wherein the divine consorts are conceived as the inseparable powers of Vishnu and His incarnations: e.g., Krishna's Rādhā Rānī and Rāma's Sitā.
Smārtism: Sakti is a divine form of Čsvara. It is God's manifesting power.

On the Nature of Personal God

Saivism: God Siva is pure love and compassion, immanent and transcendent, pleased by our purity and sādhana.
Sāktism: The Goddess Sakti is both compassionate and terrifying, pleasing and wrathful, assuaged by sacrifice and submission.
Vaishnavism: God Vishnu is loving and beautiful, the object of man's devotion, pleased by our service and surrender.
Smārtism: Čsvara appears as a human-like Deity according to devotees' loving worship, which is sometimes considered a rudimentary self-purifying practice.

On the Doctrine of Avatāra

Saivism: There are no divine earthly incarnations.
Sāktism: The Divine Mother does incarnate in this world.
Vaishnavism: Vishnu has ten or more incarnations.
Smārtism: All Deities may assume earthly incarnations.

On the Soul and God

Saivism: God Siva is one with the soul. The soul must realize this advaitic Truth by God Siva's grace.
Sāktism: The Divine Mother, Sakti, is mediatrix, bestowing advaitic moksha on those who worship Her.
Vaishnavism: God and soul are eternally distinct. Through Lord Vishnu's grace, the soul's destiny is to worship and enjoy God.
Smārtism: Čsvara and man are in reality Absolute Brahman. Within Māyā, the soul and Čsvara appear as two. Jńāna dispels the illusion.

Spiritual Practice

Saivism: With Bhakti as a base, emphasis is placed on sādhana, tapas and yoga. Ascetic
Sāktism: Emphasis is on Bhakti and tantra, sometimes occult, practices. Ascetic-occult.
Vaishnavism: Emphasis is on supreme Bhakti or surrender, called prapatti. Generally devotional and nonascetic.
Smārtism: Preparatory sādhanas are Bhakti, Karma, Rāja yoga. Highest path is through knowledge, leading to Jńāna.

Major Scriptures

Saivism: Vedas, Saiva Ćgamas and Saiva Purānas.
Sāktism: Vedas, Sākta Ćgamas (Tantras) and Purānas.
Vaishnavism: Vedas, Vaishnava Ćgamas, Purānas and the Itihāsas (Rāmāyana and Mahābhārata, especially the Bhagavad Gītā).
Smārtism: Vedas, Ćgamas and classical Smriti-Purānas, Itihāsas, especially the Bhagavad Gītā, etc.

Regions of Influence

Saivism: Geographically widespread, strongest in South and North India, Nepal and Sri Lanka.
Sāktism: Geographically widespread, most prominent in North India, especially Bengal and Assam.
Vaishnavism: Geographically widespread, especially strong throughout India, North and South.
Smārtism: Geographically widespread, most prominent in North and South India.
   
   
 
Conclusion
Please read this part after you have completed all the pages listed below

This concludes our basic comparison of Hinduism's four prominent denominations, and of other religions, faiths and philosophies. There are many more indigenous, tribal groups who follow similar paths and call themselves by unique names, and there are many more paths yet to be discovered in the future. This chapter can be a complete outline, affording to those who read it carefully a simple overview of those intangible human beliefs which, in all their variety, are at the root of attitudes and behavior, that, over time, create culture. Hopefully it could do more; perhaps mark the beginning of discovering your own place in this grand scheme. Conversion is easy into any one of these forms of worship, practice and attainment. It is happening all the time. All souls on the path to perfection eventually commit themselves by choosing a preceptor, one who has gone before. Journeying through life without a preceptor is like traversing the ocean without a map or a compass. Even climbing the slopes of the Himalayas, a Sherpa is needed to safely guide. Compare your beliefs, as they are today, with all those cataloged in this synopsis, and come to terms with the supreme dedication that each of these paths demands of its followers. Having done this, declare boldly who you are to your own self. Claim your spiritual identity, your preceptor and the religious faith to which you find you belong. Then follow your chosen path with all your heart. Give it your full devotion, energy and loyalty in fullfiling its goals. True seekers on the path hoping for genuine attainment do not wander from path to path, school to school, preceptor to preceptor, because it is known that indecision inhibits all spiritual growth.